An old, but controversial tombstone sits just  southwest of the old Sexton’s office within the Spring Vale cemetery in Lafayette, Indiana.  The story behind the Martin P. Jenners’ tombstone controversy has been written about by historians over the years with limited information extracted from minute books and a December 23, 1919 obituary that was printed in the local newspaper.  Additional details have been unearthed by the discovery of a June 22, 1907 newspaper article from The Star Press (Muncie, Indiana), which has shed new light on an old story.   Martin P. Jenners was interviewed by a reporter when he was 76 years old, twelve years before he died in 1919.   The details have been long forgotten, but here is the rest of the story story told in some of Jenners’ very own words:    From The Star Press …(Muncie, Indiana) June 22, 1907 Arraigns Religion in Unique Manner “When you are dead, that’s the end of you.   Then it’s oblivion—...