The
Exemplary Life of General Tootle
By
Diana Vice
General Tootle Takes a Stand
His
name was General Tootle. He lived up to
that name throughout his life as a respected community leader and conductor on
the local Underground Railroad. Indiana was a free state when it came to
slavery, but the Slavery Act of 1850 made it possible for Southern slave
catchers to enter free states to capture freedom-seekers who had escaped from
bondage. The unwelcome law also made it illegal for anyone to assist runaway
slaves, which included fines of $1,000 for officials caught disobeying the
law. General Tootle took a stand against
the unfair Act and secretly helped many fugitives navigate their way through
Lafayette, Indiana, and surrounding areas.
One hot summer day in 1860, General was
confronted by an aggressive slave catcher near the train station in
Crawfordsville, Indiana. The slave catcher claimed that Tootle was a runaway
slave named Jacob. The armed and angry man shoved a handbill in Tootle’s face
and yelled, “You match the description of Jacob, and I am here to arrest you!”
This made General very unhappy and put him in a worrisome dilemma since he
closely matched the physical description of the fugitive and was even wearing
similar clothing.
General
Tootle, who was also armed, quickly established his identity as a free man of
color and let Mr. Slave Catcher know that he would not be taken without a
fight. Tootle warned the armed man that he would be prudent to respect his
rights as a free American and citizen of the state of Indiana. When the slave catcher saw that Tootle was
equal to the occasion, he left the city without Jacob or General.
General
Tootle’s Escape from Slavery
The
oppressed citizens knew that if they were to succeed in a free society, they
must have an education. In 1828, a group of Quakers and several free black
families from North Carolina and Virginia traveled in a caravan of 15 wagons
and carts filled with men, women, and children.
They trudged through the mountains of West Virginia, floated across the
Ohio River at Cincinnati, until they reached Indiana. Among the weary travelers were members of the
Tootle family, including the senior General Tootle who traveled with his five
boys in a two-wheeled cart. The families
had purchased farmland from the government and formed a community known as the
Beech Settlement. The land was located on a plateau above the Blue River
bottoms, northwest of Carthage, Indiana. It received its name, because during
the earlier days, there was a grove of beech trees near the settlement. The
younger General Tootle and his brothers received an education at nearby church
schoolhouses.
General
Tootle, “King Pin of Barbers”
As the
children grew, many of them left Carthage and ventured out seeking better opportunities. Presumed brothers James “General” and Aaron “Colonel” Tootle, came to Lafayette,
Indiana, in 1844, where they opened a barber shop. In 1870, General Tootle, the self-proclaimed
“King Pin of barbers” moved his shop from under the American House near 5th
and Columbia Streets to a more spacious facility under the law office of W. W.
Wilson on Main Street, in the rear of the Second National Bank.
An advertisement
in the June 27, 1870, edition of the Journal and Courier described
Tootle’s successful profession: “It is superfluous to say anything of the
attainments of the General as a shavist, for the fact of his having grown gray
while plying his art in this city speaks for itself. He is the discoverer of a
wash for the hair that only requires to have the bottle containing the liquid
rubbed gently over the hair to produce the most extraordinary results
imaginable. It not only thoroughly cleanses the scalp but imparts a gloss unsurpassed
by either Batchelor or Christadoro. When you want to be ‘done up’ call on
Toodle.” Aaron later moved to Vincennes
where he opened his own barber shop while General Tootle, a beloved character
and member of the community, remained in Lafayette.
General
Tootle Shares a Secret
![]() |
| William A. Foster, Railroad Superintendent, worked with General Tootle on the UGRR |
Tootle counted among his friends, prominent members of the community, including Judge Cyrus and Rebecca Ball, Sheriff Martin Pierce, Dr. Elizur Deming, Lewis Falley, Jr., and William Foster, the superintendent of the New Albany and Salem (Monon) Railroad. These folks shared a dangerous secret. They were all members and worked closely together as stationmasters and conductors on the Underground Railroad. This team of brave men and women were responsible for transporting many men, women, and children to safety and freedom from Crawfordsville to Lafayette and northward to Canada.
Fugitives
Captured Near Baker’s Corner
Tootle
was not unfamiliar with the dangers of being involved with the Underground
Railroad as members of the Beech Settlement community were reportedly part of
that network. When he was about ten years old, the fascinating story of John
Rhodes and his family became headline news around the country after a man named
Singleton Vaughn traveled from Missouri to a nearby Indiana community to claim
them as his property.
According
to Hamilton County Historian David Heighway, it all began in 1837 when Vaughn
purchased three slaves – Sam Burk, his wife Maria, and their infant daughter,
Lydia. The previous owner had lived for at least six months in the free state
of Illinois, and rather than risk the slaves declaring their freedom, he sold
them back into a slave state. After it
became apparent that Vaughn was considering selling Maria and Lydia to another
slave owner, the couple decided to run away.
Sam made a raft out of logs and grapevines and crossed the Mississippi
River, but Vaughn caught up with the escapees in Illinois where they were
placed in jail. Agents of the Underground Railroad broke into the jail and
freed the slaves and sent them on their way to Canada. They were exhausted when
they reached members of the Underground Railroad in Hamilton County.
The
area was considered an abolitionist stronghold, so Sam and Maria decided to
make their home among their new friends and changed their names to John and
Louanne Rhodes. They eventually
purchased ten acres of land near Baker’s Corner and became respected members of
the community. Their safety was once
again threatened in 1844 when Singleton Vaughn discovered their location. He traveled to Hamilton County with a small
posse, and after a short stand-off, Vaughn was able to capture the fugitives. A crowd of neighbors showed up in support of
the Rhodes’ family. As they were traveling to the Noblesville courthouse to be
arraigned, Daniel Jones whipped the horses and scurried the family away toward
Westfield in a daring great escape. The Rhodes family were free again thanks to
the miraculous intervention.
The
trouble was not over for those who helped the fugitives. Vaughn sued Owen
Williams for the loss of his property since he had sold John Rhodes the land
for his cabin. Local Quakers created a defense fund to help fight the uphill
battle. The judge made it clear that the trial was not about whether slavery
was right, but only about the legal status of the Rhodes family. During the
trial, it was revealed the Rhodes had lived in a free state before he purchased
them. Since the ordeal occurred prior to
the passage of the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850 and the Dred Scott decision in
1854, the jury found for the defendants and Vaughn returned to Missouri
empty-handed.
The
story of the Rhodes family’s continued struggle for freedom was likely in the
back of General Tootle’s mind that day when he was confronted by the angry
slave catcher in Crawfordsville, and it was a possible motivation for his
determination to continue with this dangerous work.
A
Daring Escape from Crawfordsville to Canada
Another
encounter that was likely on General Tootle’s mind during his dangerous
missions was one that was later featured in the New England Magazine and
retold by Historian A. W. Bowen in The History of Montgomery County, Indiana,
Vol. II, 1911. It is likely that Tootle
and his compatriots had first-hand knowledge of this harrowing ordeal and knew
some of the players involved. “In 1848,
a mulatto girl, about twenty years old, comely in appearance and possessing a
fair education, reached the home of the father of Sidney Speed, of
Crawfordsville, Indiana.”
The
story was told by Mr. Speed in the following language: “She was secreted in the
garret over the old log house, or rather its kitchen where fugitives were
usually kept when there was any danger. There she had to remain several days
owing to the presence of her pursuers in the neighborhood. Suspicion soon
rested on Mr. Speed and he began to receive visits from strangers, men who made
believe that they wanted information about live stock deals in the town, and
they hoped in the mean time to get a glimpse of the escaped slave. The girl’s
place of hiding was seen to be no longer safe, so one dark night she was
hurried across lot to a colored family called Patterson and here she was
arrayed ‘in a fine costume of silk and ribbons as it was possible to procure at
that time.’ She was then furnished with a white baby that had been borrowed for
the occasion, and thus disguised as a lady and accompanied by one of the
Patterson girls as a servant and nurse, she boarded the train at the station.
Great was her surprise and shock, when she observed that on the same car was
her former owner and master, he, having failed on his errand in Crawfordsville,
concluded to follow along to see what he might discover later on. Her courage
and lady-like composure did not desert her however, and Detroit was safely
reached. Here she boarded the ferryboat for Canada. As the boat was about to
start, she sent ashore her pretended maid with the borrowed baby, and just as
the gangplank was being raised, lifted her veil that she might bid her owner
goodbye. The master, deeply angered, gazed at her departure, the same being as
real as the situation was gratifying to her and the amusement of bystanders.
The
house mentioned in Crawfordsville where the girl was secreted, has been
preserved and stands in monument in the town park next to the local chapter
house of the Dorothy Q. Chapter, Daughters of the American Revolution.
General
Tootle Goes to War
![]() |
| General George Wagner |
General Tootle didn’t shy away from danger after the Civil War broke out, and he never allowed racism to hinder the love he felt for his country. Tootle worked his entire life to advance the civil rights for his brethren, and he never allowed unjust laws or regulations to deter him.
Congress
did not allow for the enlistment of African American men in the Union Army
until July 1862. Once accepted into service, African Americans served in
segregated units and contributed greatly to the success of the war effort. The Bethel African Methodist Episcopalian
Church (AME) located at 10th and Cincinnati Streets was used as a
recruitment center for members of the local African American community. Tootle
enlisted as part of the 15th Colored Indiana Infantry. According to
a pension claim deposition for Isaac M. Wheeler in 1889, Tootle wrote, “I was
in the service as a messenger for Gen’l Wagner, Col. of the 15th
Indiana.” General Wagner led his troops at
the Battle of Franklin on November 30, 1864, in Franklin, Tennessee. It was one
of the worst disasters for the Confederate Army.
General
Tootle’s Fights for Civil Rights
![]() |
| Frederick Douglass |
speakers to Lafayette. The most prominent speaker to visit Lafayette was the great Frederick Douglass, who was instrumental in helping Lafayette’s African American community raise funds to purchase the historic Bethel AME Church building from the Lutheran Church. On April 19, 1867, Douglass spoke for nearly two and a half hours in a standing room only sanctuary of a neighboring Baptist Church.
“He
stood before his audience…calm, majestic, impressive – the true type of a
self-made man, rising superior to the circumstances which chained him down, and
achieving greatness in the face of unreasoning greatness in the face of
unreasoning prejudice and unscrupulous wrong,” stated the writer of the
article.
Douglass,
the most photographed man of the 20th century was a friend of
Sheriff Martin Peirce and presumably General Tootle, who worked to bring the
famous orator to the Lafayette community.
General
Tootle Elected Captain of Grant and Wilson Club
General
Tootle was always the go-to guy when it came to leading others. In 1872 he was elected as captain of the
Grant and Wilson Club, a militia formed to support the Republican presidential
ticket of Ulysses S. Grant and Henry Wilson, national leaders in the opposition
of slavery. An August 6, 1872, article
in the Journal and Courier reported on Tootle’s election for the
prestigious Honor.
“At
the close of the regular religious services at the African Methodist Episcopal
Church last evening, George Movedo in the chair, a Grant and Wilson Club was
organized by the election of Dewis Cumming President. All present, some
thirty-five or forty, joined the organization, a company of Tanners was formed
and General Toodles elected as captain.”
After announcing resolutions for the newly formed organization, it was
reported there was “great enthusiasm” for the cause, and that “they met at the
African M.E. Church to make arrangements to join in the ovation to Senator
Wilson.”
“Captain”
General Tootle, along with H. Field and W. Cumming, signed a resolution in 1874
at the AME Church, honoring the sacrifices of Charles Sumner, a senator and outspoken
opponent of slavery who suffered a severe beating for the cause. The resolution
was unanimously adopted by its members.
“Resolved, That in the Hon. Charles Sumner we recognize our early and lasting friend, in fact, the very Moses who led our race from bondage to liberty—and that by his great ability, his upright character we honor and revere him as the ‘protector of the oppressed and the defender of true constitutional liberty.’
“Resolved,
that a copy of these resolutions be forwarded to the Mayor of Boston and to the
Governor of the State of Massachusetts, as a token of our great grief at the
death of her distinguished son.”
General
Tootle’s Barbershop News
During
his career, General Tootle set up a barbershop in a few locations throughout
the downtown area in Lafayette, Indiana, including across from the courthouse
on Columbia Street, in the basement of the Bramble House, East Main Street, and
in the basement of the Reynolds’ Union National Bank building. In 1853 he, along with his brother, Aaron
Tootle, John H. Morris, Asbery Hill, and W. S. Morris, published a notice of a
“Barber’s Strike” in the newspaper. This was in reaction to landlords
increasing building rents. It was
certainly a clever way to place the blame on others for the price increases.
“We,
the Barber’s of Lafayette, in consequence of the increased prices of Rents,
living, & c., are completed to Strike. We shall charge the following
rates for work,
Shaving…10
Hair
Cutting…15
Going
out to shave the sick…50
Shaving
the dead…$2.00
In
1869, General Tootle pleaded guilty to “indulging in the pleasures of the
tonsorial art on the Sabbath and was fined one dollar and costs.”
Thomas
L. Gibbs Dies Suddenly in Tootle’s Barber Shop
In
1878, General Tootle’s barbershop made headline news after Thomas Gibbs died
suddenly in his barbershop. A Coroner’s
Inquest was commissioned to determine the cause of what was labeled as a
“mysterious death.”
“We
are today obliged to chronicle another sudden and mysterious death in our
midst. Yesterday afternoon at about 8 o’clock, a man named Thomas L. Gibbs,
called at the office of Dr. Walker, and asked for some medicine, complaining of
a severe pain in his head. The Doctor made an examination of the man and found
him to be in a very feeble condition, his pulse being but about thirty beats a
minute. A powder was given to him and a hack sent for to convey him to his
home, but before this arrived Gibbs became impatient and started away on foot,
proceeding up Fifth Street. He next stopped at Yeakel’s drug store and called
for a glass of whiskey. This was refused him, and he started up Columbia
Street, stopping at Tootle’s barber shop and asking permission to stop and warm
himself. He was told that he had best go home, but after he had passed, Tootle,
noticing that he seemed unwell, followed him and brought him back. He was then
placed in one of the chairs, and after complaining of a sickness of the
stomach, fell into what the barbers supposed to be a sleep. When they
approached some moments after, this man was found to be a corpse. Aid was at
once summoned, and upon examination it was found that the deceased lived upon
the bank of the river near the termination of Alabama Street. He has been, for
the last two years, quite dissipated, a small quantity of liquor intoxicating
him, but was not under the influence of drink yesterday. He leaves a small
family. After some consultation the following verdict was agreed upon:
‘We, the undersigned, Jurors,
empaneled and sworn, on the 15th day of December, in the year 1878,
at the township of Fairfield, in the county of Tippecanoe, by Silas T. Yount,
Coroner of said county of Tippecanoe, by Silas T. Yount, Coroner of said
county, to inquire and true presentment make, in what manner Thomas L. Gibbs,
whose body was found at the barber shop of Jeneral Tootles, on Columbia Street
between Fourth and Fifth, on the 15th day of December, in the year
1878, came to his death. After having heard the evidence, and examined the
body, we do find that the deceased came to his death by means of paralysis of
the heart.’
Signed James W. Jefferson, Ph. H.
Sheehan, John Murphy, M. H. Kenuaday, Nat S. Wood, Charles C. Pike. Given under
our hands, at the time and place of said inquisition above mentioned. -SILAS T. YOUNT, Coroner.”
The
Death of Mrs. Tootle
Not
much is known about the early life of Elizabeth Cook. Born in 1831 in
Washington, D.C., she came to Lafayette as a child to be raised in the home of
Judge Andrew and Emily Ingraham. Judge Ingram was a prominent citizen who was
actively involved in his church, St. John’s Episcopal. Judge Ingram was so
revered in his church that upon his death in 1865, the rector published a resolution
in the local newspaper.
A
few of the details included in the resolution revealed that Ingraham was one of
the church’s “oldest and most faithful members” where he served in “responsible
positions,” and brought “rare wisdom into her councils, and who illustrated in
his life, the purity and excellence of her faith.” It was written that he “was so sincerely
cherished by the members” of the church and worthy in his private, public, and
Christian virtues.
Knowing
that Elizabeth Cook (Tootle) was raised in the home of Judge Ingram, it is safe
to assume that she was a woman of high character and morals. It is likely General Tootle was required to
ask the judge for Elizabeth’s hand in marriage, which was given on May 3, 1849.
General Tootle and Elizabeth Cook were married in the Ingram home.
When
Mrs. Tootle died in 1879 at the age of 47, the Ingram family gifted two grave
sites to the Tootles within their family plot at the Greenbush Cemetery in
Lafayette. Mrs. Tootle had contracted a
lung disease in 1876 and suffered until February 24, 1879, when she passed away
in the home she shared with her husband at 138 Main Street. Her funeral was held at the Bethel AME Church
and conducted by the Rev. H. A. Gobin, a man of great influence in the state.
At
the conclusion of the funeral, a great number of her friends followed the body
to its last resting place. Mrs. Tootle’s
obituary reported that she had “many warm personal friends, and will be sadly
missed among her circle.” Her husband was described as “the well-known colored
barber.”
General
Tootle, First Lieutenant of Garfield Guards
The
April 28, 1880, edition of the Journal and Courier reported that General
Tootle applied for a position as a sleeping car conductor for the
railroad. It is unclear as to whether he
received the job; however, the write-up mentioned that Tootle “served with
distinction on the Underground Railroad,” and since his reputation in the
community was quite impressive, one can assume he likely received the position.
Since this was within in a year of his wife’s passing it could be that Tootle
was looking to keep his mind off such a tragic loss.
Tootle
found another way to keep busy after his wife’s death when he was elected in
August of 1880 as First Lieutenant of The Colored Republican Garfield Guards,
one of many such local militias that were organized throughout the country in
honor of President James A. Garfield.
Garfield,
a former Civil War General was revered by African American soldiers as a
staunch ally against slavery as well as suffrage for Black Americans. “What is freedom?” Garfield once asked. “Is
it the bare privilege of not being chained? If this is all, then freedom is a
bitter mockery, a cruel delusion.” This
was in
The
African American militia organization was formed at the Courthouse and the
names of thirty-five voters were counted. They met for drills and continued to
recruit new members. Uniforms were ordered and it was said that these men
“fought nobly during the war.” “We are glad to see our colored fellow-citizens
organizing for the campaign,” the writer stated.
When
President Garfield was shot on July 2, 1881, many of Garfield’s Guards stood
vigil nearby. Less than two and a half
months after the shooting, President Garfield succumbed to a post-surgical
infection and passed away on September 19, 1881. Members of Garfield’s Guards stood vigil near
the murdered body of their beloved president. After his burial, the remains of
the martyred president were still watched by the soldiers.
A
January 29, 1883, edition of the Fort Wayne Daily Gazette reported, “No
one is allowed to approach within 100 yards of Garfield’s tomb after nightfall
until they have been identified by the guard who still paces ceaselessly back
and forth every hour day and night, except in stormy weather, when he sits at
an open window in a little guardhouse that stands just across the road and two
or three rods from the vault, in front of which a light must be kept burning…These
guards will not be removed until the body rests safely beneath the monument.”
The
following poem was published in the newspaper after President Garfield’s
assassination attempt. It was to be sung to the tune of Yankee Doodle. One stanza read, “We will not wave the
bloody shirt, No hint in that direction; Yet men shall vote, and not be hurt,
No matter what complexion.”
General
Tootle Chosen as Grand Marshal
On
Wednesday, September 22, 1880, men who were invited to speak to the crowd were
J. Willis, G. Wilson, J. Warren, and C. W. Beach. Col. R. P. DeHart was one of
the evening speakers. Weaver’s Band furnished the music, and the jubilee
singers also performed at the gala that was held at Blue Ribbon Hall in
Lafayette.
General
Tootle’s “Fiery” Sermon
Inspired by his religious upbringing, General Tootle was active in his church, and he obviously had a passion for preaching. The June 16, 1884, edition of the Journal and Courier recounted one such sermon that ended in a near tragedy. Titled as “The Faith that Moves Mountains, the article reported the following:
“General
Toodle, the colored barber whose neat little shop on East Main Street is
familiar to us all, is a powerful preacher and exhorter as well as a skillful
tonsorial artist. His impressive earnestness occasioned trouble in the house of
worship on one occasion and abruptly and ingloriously terminated the services
over which he was presiding. This was one Sunday during the past severe winter.
Brother Toodle was in the midst of an exhortation on faith – the faith that
moves mountains and works miracles, when the stove, which had arrived at the
state of red-hot enthusiasm amidst the ‘hallelujahs’ and ‘amens,’ of the
emotion-swayed congregation suddenly lost its equilibrium and fell over. A
serious conflagration was imminent.
‘Pick up de
stove! Pick up de stove!’ shouted Brother Toodle. But no one seemed disposed to
make a holocaust of himself even though commanded to do so by so resistless and
magnetic an orator as Brother Toodle. Pointing his long index finger at a
grey-haired brother, who stood with a dazed and bewildered expression, gazing
at the overturned stove. Brother Toodle vociferated: ‘Pick up de stove, Brother
Hord; de good Lor won’t let it burn yo.’
Scandal
and Commotion in Tootle’s Barber Emporium
General
Tootle’s barbershop seems to have been a public gathering place. The April 21,
1890, edition of the Journal and Courier tells of one such scene that
surely became the talk of the town that day as it involved a woman’s claim and
threat to have Will Tracey, a coachman in the employ of Adams Earl, arrested
for bastardy.
The article,
entitled, “Misplaced Confidence,” reads, “About 8 o’clock this morning
Miss Ella Grant, colored, entered General Tootle’s barber emporium on the
Market Space and created quite a commotion. She was in search of her pretended
lover, Will Tracey, coachman in the employ of Adams Earl whom she was going to
have arrested for bastardy. She failed to find him and went to the office of
Noah Justice and swore out a warrant for Tracey’s arrest. Her statement is that
he promised to marry her, and she says he has got to keep his word, or she will
make it so warm for him that he will want to jump into the Wabash River. At
this writing, Constable Somerville is in search of Tracey. On the arrival of
Tracey, he agreed to marry Miss Grant and as soon as a license could be secured
‘Squire Justice performed with usual grace and dignity the happy ceremony. His
words of advice to the young couple were full of wisdom.
In 1901, the
Lafayette Sunday Times included General Tootle in a story about
“Conspicuous Characters of Lafayette of Long Ago,” referring to him as a
“prominent resident.” It described General Tootle as “about as slick citizens
as you could meet in a day’s journey,” and how he had “mysterious whisperings
with certain ladies.” According to the article, Tootle was also known as a
“retailer of the scandal magazine of Lafayette.”
General Tootle’s Last Days
Due to deteriorating health, General Tootle was taken to “the county poor farm” for proper care in 1891, when he could no longer care for himself, and a year later, on June 17, 1892, he passed away. Trustee Sims solicited donations to “pay for a suitable casket” and to bury the remains by the side of his wife in Greenbush Cemetery. According to the June 17, 1892, edition of the Journal and Courier, enough money was collected to purchase an elegant casket and provide for an honorable burial.
The following obituary for the beloved citizen
was published on June 19, 1892, by the Lafayette Sunday Leader:
“Janeral
Tootle, the well-known colored barber, who died at the county asylum, Friday
morning, was buried with all the honors of a veteran. Mr. Tootle was all
through the war, contributing all in his power for the comfort of Sale Fry and
other union soldiers, but he was never sworn into service. Trustee Job Sims,
whose admiration for a soldier will cause him to do a great deal, went around among
the boys, and secured the funds necessary to give Mr. Tootle an honorable
burial, and his body reposes beside that of his wife, who died several years
ago. Mr. Tootle was one of the best-known colored men in Lafayette. Of late
years his health has been very bad, and being out of funds, he was sent to the
county asylum. The LEADER wrote quite a long account of Mr. Tootle’s life some
months ago.” [This referenced newspaper is missing from the library archives;
therefore, much about Tootle’s life remains missing.]
General Tootle was a local hero whose valuable contributions to society may have been forgotten had it not been for Historian Mary Anthrop’s efforts to preserve his memory in this TCHA blogpost. Local businesswoman extraordinaire, Paula Davis, has also championed Tootle’s important role as a conductor on the local Underground Railroad. This continued work is dedicated to the sacrifices of General Tootle and all those who sacrificed much in the name of equality for all.













Comments
Post a Comment